Gnocchi by Sharing The Food We Love

Homemade gnocchi is one of those foods that I thought would be difficult to make and had consequently never attempted to try.  I had visions of my dumplings being a messy glue that would dissolve at cooking or turn into bullets and leave us with a horrid pasty texture in our mouths.   Never one to be able to resist a challenge in my kitchen I got it into my mind to overturn this perception this month when the book of the month for The Cookbook Guru was Marcella Hazan’s Classic Italian Cookbook.   I thought if ever I’m going to be able to make these then the best place to start is learning from one of the experts in Italian food.

As the month has gone on one of my biggest hurdles to overcome was in finding the right potatoes.  Hazan recommends using Desiree or a similar waxy style, but not new potatoes.  Ironically I’d been seeing these potatoes around in different places for months but when I actually wanted them the only options were dutch creams, ruby lou’s and other creamy styles which I knew wouldn’t work.  Finally I got the time on a Saturday to visit my potato man at the Kelvin Grove Village markets and was rewarded with a plethora of choice.  Sticking to the master’s recommendation I went with Desiree’s for my first attempt.

I’m sure you can imagine my delight and surprise when I attempted to make these last night and they worked!  Whilst I still believe there is room for improvement to the flavour and texture I did end up with pillows which were light and tasty and held their form well.  I found them a lot easier to make than I expected and didn’t need any fancy equipment either.  Whilst they take some time to make and are not for a quick weekday meal I don’t think gnocchi should be a dish that you run away from either.  They were a perfect partner to a creamy green sauce with pan-fried ham that I made to go with them.

In a nutshell these are Hazan’s rules of must to get great gnocchi:

  • use “older potatoes”
  • the potatoes need to be a waxy style… the potatoes that you use mean EVERYTHING to the texture
  • make sure to cook the potatoes whole and don’t test them too many times to avoid water logging
  • test cook your gnocchi to ascertain the right cooking time, rather than just blindly following the recipe.  Each batch will be slightly different.
  • egg will make your gnocchi easier to handle but is also more likely to make the texture tough.

Potato Gnocchi

* serves 4

  • 675g desiree potatoes, whole
  • 175g plain flour

Bring a large pot of water to the boil, add a dash of salt, and then place your potatoes in whole with the skins still on.  Cook until they just give in the centre with a fork, taking care not to test the potatoes too many times to avoid them becoming waterlogged.  Drain immediately and allow to cool slightly so that you can handle them.  You do still want them to be hot when making the gnocchi though so don’t let them get cold.

If you are going to eat your gnocchi straight away get your cooking pot ready by placing another large pot of water onto the stove and bring to the boil.  Turn down to a simmer and leave ready to go.   Prepare you sauce and have warm in a fry pan and ready to add the gnocchi too as it cooks.IMG_9591

Carefully peel the potatoes whilst they are warm using a tea towel to protect your fingers and a sharp paring knife.  Pass the potato through a fine sieve or potato mill into a bowl.  Add 150g of the flour and combine into a dough until smooth.  The mixture should be just slightly sticky to the touch so add more flour if it’s still too gluey.


Sprinkle your bench top with plain flour and then divide the mixture in half and roll into a long sausage.  Cut the gnocchi into even sized pillows.


To cook, place 2 or 3 gnocchi into the simmering water and allow to cook until they float to the top of the water.  Cook for another 5 seconds and then remove them from the water with a slotted spoon.  If your gnocchi is still slightly floury or chewy then cook for about another 10 seconds.  Once you feel confident about the cooking time cook your gnocchi in batches, taking care not to crowd the pot or they will stick together.


If they start to fall apart then shorten your cooking time by about the same.   Mine did have a slight resistance when I removed then from the saucepan by I then finished them off in the sauce to complete the cooking process.

Serve the gnocchi coated in your favourite sauce and topped with a generous sprinkle of Grana Padano.  Gnocchi goes beautifully with a simple tomato (Napolitana) sauce, pesto or even a Gorgonzola cheese sauce.  For me though I tried this delicious and low fat green sauce and it balanced the flavour wonderfully.  See below for a quick recipe on how to make it.


For any gnocchi that you’re not eating you can freeze them prior to the boiling stage by putting them into the freezer on a tray and then storing in a plastic bag once they have gone solid.  They will keep in the freezer for up to a month.

My Green Sauce

*adapted from Broccoli and Bacon Sauce by Please Pass The Recipe

  • stems of 4 brocolli
  • 1 long stalk of celery
  • 8 asparagus stalks (optional)
  • 2 cloves garlic
  • 150g ham, finely sliced (optional)
  • olive oil
  • salt and cracked black pepper to taste.

Place the brocolli, celery, asparagus and garlic into a small saucepan and fill with just enough water to cover the contents.  Place on a high heat and simmer until the stalks are cooked through.  Remove from the heat and using a stick mixer puree the contents until smooth.  Pour in a small amount of olive oil (about 1-2 tbl sp) until the mixture takes on a creamy type consistency and then season to taste.  You can cook the flowers from the used brocolli to serve with your pasta, although I chose not to in this instance.

To serve,  stir through your pasta and serve with either parmesan or smoked cheese.  I also added some pan-fried ham and a few sage leaves to the sauce for my above gnocchi and it was delicious.

Shared With Love,


This post is also a contribution towards Our Growing Edge.


12 Comments Add yours

  1. ladyredspecs says:

    Well gone Leah! I love gnocchi, but then I love potatoes. I like your green sauce adaptation too, perfect for spring! Xxxx


    1. Leah says:

      Thank you! I was quite pleased with myself for how these turned out and the green sauce was fabulous with them 🙂 xx


  2. Leah says:

    Reblogged this on The Cookbook Guru and commented:

    A last minute recipe to share with you all. I’ve been planning to make this all month and finally was able to get the time and the ingredients together last night, just in time to be a part of our Hazan Cookbook Guru for the month.


  3. Great tips Leah! i love that you have a “potato man”. I didn’t know that waxy potatoes should be used. I just assumed that floury was better for gnocchi.

    I’ve only made gnocchi once but I found the fine sieve part hard work and never made it a second time! A friend of mine said she never uses a sieve but just mashes it really well. That sounds much easier.

    This post would make a great addition to Our Growing Edge this month.


    1. Leah says:

      Thanks Genie. It was a good lesson reading up on Hazan’s tips. I’m no longer so intimidated by gnocchi which is a joy as I love eating it. I’ll definately link it for Our Growing Edge, thats a great idea 🙂


  4. I had the same thought about making gnocchi – that they would either dissolve into a sticky mass in the sauce or become hard little lead pellets that would sit in the stomach refusing to be digested. Well, I guess after your glorious triumph here, you’ve created a bit of a challenge (a good, non-competitive one, that is). Gnocchi experiments are now marked on my list of things to try.


    1. Leah says:

      Oh do try them Debi, with your food experience and creativity I’m sure you’ll rock them! 🙂


  5. Corina says:

    These sound really good. I’ve only made gnocchi a couple of times and they are fun to made but definitely something for when you’ve got a bit of time.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Leah says:

      Thank you Corina, I agree with you entirely. I was actually surprised that they were quicker to make than I expected but its not a quick midweek dinner like other pasta’s. Thank you for stopping by and commenting.


  6. chef mimi says:

    Great tips, and beautiful gnocchi! I especially love your green sauce. So smart!


    1. Leah says:

      Thank you. I’m really happy with how the whole thing turned out. I wouldn’t hesitate to make them again. If you get a chance, give the green sauce a go, it’s so simple and very tasty 🙂


Share your thoughts, we love to hear them....

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s